Each of the three Premier League goals scored by the forward in this campaign have been away from home.
At a glance
Forest move past Spurs into sixteenth place, three points above the relegation places.
Igor Jesus heads Forest in front moments before half-time.
The England midfielder adds a second and substitute the Nigerian forward seals the victory.
Spurs sit only one point clear of the bottom three and have failed to win a league game this calendar year.
Nottingham Forest took a giant leap to safety and plunged their hosts deeper into the drop fight with a comprehensive victory in North London.
The Forest striker, their playmaker and a late substitute decided the crucial clash to lift their team a valuable margin away from the bottom three.
Forest leapfrogged their opponents in the standings, leaving Tottenham a point above the bottom three following other results.
This result throws renewed uncertainty over the position of Tottenham interim manager Igor Tudor, who has been at the helm for a brief spell.
Tottenham failed to sign Gibbs-White in the previous transfer window, a protracted pursuit which saw Forest threatening Spurs with legal action.
Fast forward seven-and-a-half months, the England midfielder's strike could have helped push Tottenham nearer the second tier in a pivotal outcome for Forest – the maiden victory in the top flight under manager Vitor Pereira after he joined this year.
Spurs have now not won in the Premier League dating back to 28 December, suffering six defeats in seven matches and are falling apart under Tudor's stewardship.
The Croatian has suffered defeat in five of his seven matches at the helm and Sunday's result may prove the most damaging of all.
The home side were on top in the first half but Igor Jesus – who had earlier turned the ball onto his own crossbar – nodded in the first goal in added time before the break.
Mathys Tel struck the woodwork just before halftime as the hosts sought an instant response but conceded again after 62 minutes when Gibbs-White was left unmarked in the area and his shot from a teammate's pull-back went through the goalkeeper's hands.
Once Tottenham replacement Lucas Bergvall blazed a good opportunity off target, there was no coming back and the substitute added a third with three minutes left, leaving Tottenham with a handful of fixtures to save their Premier League future.
Spurs Breakdown: Manager Under Fire with Spurs Cheered On and Booed Off
Where do this Tottenham side now?
It could not have been any more damaging if they tried and another loss in seven Premier League games pushes them closer to relegation.
The manager's job must now be under serious scrutiny just over one month since his appointment as the previous manager's replacement.
Tudor has earned just a point from his five Premier League games and suffered a humiliation against Forest – who were without a win in the Premier League for eight weeks.
Spurs are in turmoil and face the prospect of dropping from the top flight for the first time in decades.
It could have been scripted. Spurs did start with positive intent amid support from the supporters but that spirit disappeared in the latter period.
The opening strike silenced Tottenham Hotspur Stadium and the second goal was the signal for a section of supporters to head for the exits.
Awoniyi added more pain but following just two home league wins this term – versus two other sides – it should not come as a surprise.
The team were supported and booed off and their top-division future is ever more in the balance.
Nottingham Forest Analysis: Pereira's Maiden League Victory for 11 Months Proves Vital for Forest
The Forest boss had not won in the top flight since way back in last April.
His departure from Wolves in November winless this season and it required five attempts to secure three top-flight points at the City Ground but it could prove massive for their season.
Battling defeats against strong opposition deserved more while a draw at Manchester City showed the team's ability and grit.
It was Nottingham Forest's another three-goal victory against Tottenham in the league this season, the first coming under their former manager in December, and it was equally merited.
Away from home, they survived any, light, storm in the first 40 minutes and seldom appeared under threat after the first goal.
Igor Jesus has scored just three goals in the Premier League this season after a multi-million pound transfer from Botafogo in the off-season.
Each one have earned Forest points, with a 1-0 win at Molineux and a 2-0 victory at Brentford. Sunday's header was his 13th goal of the campaign, with seven arriving in the Europa League.
But none may prove as crucial as today's effort as the team build momentum after their midweek dramatic victory which earned a Europa League quarter-final with Porto.
There will be a strong conviction they can avoid relegation from here, with West Ham and Tottenham potentially left to battle for their top-flight lives.
What's Next for These Teams?
Spurs visit the Stadium of Light in the Premier League on 12 April while Nottingham Forest journey to Portugal for their Europa League quarter-final first leg on 9 April before they welcome Aston Villa in the league on the same weekend.